Fabrica Website

Fabrica Development Team

Fabrica/Benetton

posted by Francesca Granato
on 05 February 2008


this project has been
viewed 544 times

Fabrica-browser-medium

I felt I should draw attention to the new Fabrica website. Strangely, the new site was NOT designed by the Fabrica Interactive team, headed by Andy Cameron. Apparently this new site has been designed by the newfangled 'Fabrica Development Team'. Perhaps Daniel Hirschmann (ex Fabrica webmaster, and co-founder of Fabricanti.com) can tell us more.

Briefly, for those of you who don't know. Fabrica is a Creative Design Think-Tank in Treviso, Italy. It offers year-long fellowships to a selection of young artists from around the world. It was founded by Luciano Benetton and Oliviero Toscani in 1996 and it is part of the Benetton company.

The new website is radically different from what was before. As with any organisation's web re-design, I know there has been some controversial internal reactions to the changes. Both Helder Araújo and Juliana Loh (ex-Fabrica members) drew my attention to the new website, when they both commented on it in our mailing list correspondence. I'd love it if they, or others, would like to offer their opinions publicly here.

As part of the Fabrica "alumni" myself, I quite like the new site. Selfishly, I like it because it offers me the opportunity to keep my profile updated and keep in contact with people. Whereas the old site offered no such facilities. The network of Fabrica is maturing and growing and it feels more and more important to recognize and connect each generation. Which, is a philosophy behind many of today's most-used sites (facebook springs to mind).

I suspect a lot of what keeps the site dynamic, is user-generated content from spin-off sites such as www.fabricanti.com and fabricanti.com/wiki/index.php. (But perhaps I'm mistaken, please do correct me if I'm wrong).

The interface can be tricky to grasp at first. However, my bet, is that this is intentional. The 'Projects Section' impressively opens it's own browser inside the site. This is initially a bit disorientating, but it is a system which I quickly understood (although I doubt someone less web-savvy, like say, my Mum would have the aptitude or patience for).

Concerning the navigation, interestingly, each box that opens from the main menu stays open. So you have multiple boxes open at one time. This fills the otherwise odd amount of blank white space on the home page, and leaves a nice visual history of all the info you've encountered. This wouldn't work for all types of site, but Fabrica has kept all text short and to-the-point. It is like site made of a bullet points. This minimal design is brave and it has an ethos I can sympathize with, but it does seam to leave out a lot of the substance that makes Fabrica famous. The site could feel slightly shallow, and I'm left wanting to see more work, more projects, more photographs. Fabrica (and Benetton) have always been image driven brands. It is a pity there isn't more images on this site.

There is a valid argument that says: Fabrica has produced stunning work over the last 10 years, and it should show it off. But then again, I'm tempted to argue: why should Fabrica's website be condemned to a role of archiving and displaying? It isn't a glass exhibition cabinet.

On a personal note, I'm going to see how I feel about this site when its been around a bit longer. I think it might be a grower.


http://www.fabrica.it/

Current rating

1 of us thinks this looks good

2 of us think this is no good

rate this project

rate this project

We'd like you to rate a project for success in three different areas. Tick looks good if it is aesthetically pleasing, and tick works well if it is technically innovative. Most importantly tick performs effectively if you think it meets all of its professional objectives.


Obviously we don't really expect to see any work submitted that is no good, but you never know.

please log in to add the project rating

what's been said

posted by Annalisa Merelli
on 06 February 2008

I personally don't like the browser thing. I don't know if it's a design problem but it ends up making the interface pretty inconsistent. I also miss the personal pages (I know, they can be surfed in the 2005/2007 website, but what about new Fabricanti), it was a good way of showing personal projects. Then why taking off information about Fabrica (application process and stuff) and put them in a pdf? Basically I find this website chooses the longest way possible to get to any information needed without adding anything relevant to the old one...

posted by Juan Ospina
on 06 February 2008

not an improvement

I would say i agree with the previous comment. Relevant information has been "buried" down in the website,students projects have been given less importance and the usability of the site is nowhere near as it was before. It would almost seem than rather than being a redesign, this website is a sort of "skin" placed on top of what was there. Probably Fabrica's management did not want to improve on the current features and was more concerned with the "one-to-many" showcasing of their ongoing exhibitions in China and Japan. All this of course reflects the change of focus that has been going on inside the institute for the last years, so in a way, this is the site that Fabrica wanted and the makers delivered that. Furthermore, the "Student" sections that the reviewer enjoyed are hijacked from another site fabricanti.com. Is not a bad thing entirely but they don't acknowledge in any way that this part of the site doesn't actually belong to fabrica.it, it just looks as if you never left their site and that seems a but dishonest. I had written on my blog more about this, so if you are interested here's some more information about this new site: http://www.piterwilson.com/personal/2008/02/01/the-new-fabricait-site/

posted by Francesca Granato
on 06 February 2008

What was the brief?

Very interesting comments from Juan and Annalisa. Both Juan and Annalisa say that the process of reaching the relevant and useful information has been over-complicated.

I agree with Juan's description of the current site as a 'skin' that has been wrapped around the old site. What I still don't understand is WHY has this skin been applied? What was the brief for this website re-design?

I might hazard a guess that internal-politics regarding the new role of Fabrica has lead to a demand for a more opaque and impenetrable site. Fabrica has never liked opening its doors to the public.

Something like this: http://www.gif-king.de/gifs/img10846.htm , might improve the site, as suggested by ex-Fabrica member, Florian Toperngpong. I agree with Florian, I think this kind of thing would really bring the site to life.

posted by Francesca Granato
on 06 February 2008

By the way, just to be clear: Florian wasn't serious about his 'suggestion to improve the site'! In any case, he was referring to a tounge-in-cheek 'alternate' design that has been circulating among us, ex-fabricanti. However, I think these cute animated gifs are an improvement whatever site their on. Especially this one: http://www.gifanimations.com/animation/ImageDisplay/1/4/2

posted by Juan Ospina
on 15 February 2008

what were they thinking?

i found another lack of foresight on behalf of the re-makers of fabtica.it

http://www.piterwilson.com/personal/2008/02/15/former-projects-at-fabricait-offline/

please log in to add a comment